Chalangarian told Kautsky a social democratic group had formed in Tabriz, split into two factions: one holding that foreign investment would speed capitalist development, so that resisting it built 'barricades against European civilization'; the other defending the revolution as the cause of masses exploited by landlords, clearing ground for an indigenous capitalist class. Kautsky replied on 1 August that foreign capital 'obstructs the development of the home market', that hostility to it was a positive element linking the East's movement to the West's proletarian struggle, and that Iranian social democrats should work inside the democratic movement — while writing off the small peasants as a 'reactionary' element, a judgement Afary marks as an extension of his misreading of the European peasantry.